Everything You Need to Know About Buying a Used Toyota Highlander

used toyota highlander used toyota highlander

🌟 Why the Toyota Highlander Stands Out

If you’re on the hunt for a dependable, family-friendly SUV, the used Toyota Highlander should be at the top of your list. Known for its legendary reliability, spacious interior, and strong resale value, the Highlander has built a reputation as one of the best mid-size SUVs money can buy.

💰 The Appeal of Buying a Used Toyota Highlander

Buying used can save you thousands of dollars while still delivering an SUV that feels new. With smart shopping, you can find models that are just a few years old, with low mileage, premium features, and solid warranties.


🕰 A Brief History of the Toyota Highlander

🛠 First Generation (2001–2007)

Toyota launched the Highlander to bridge the gap between rugged SUVs and family sedans. It was one of the first crossover SUVs built on a car platform, offering smooth rides and decent space.

🔧 Second Generation (2008–2013)

A redesign added more room, improved powertrains, and safety features like stability control. This gen also introduced hybrid models with impressive fuel economy.

🚙 Third Generation (2014–2019)

This generation brought sharper styling, better materials, and more tech—touchscreens, Bluetooth, and available AWD became the norm.

🚀 Fourth Generation (2020–Present)

The latest generation focuses on efficiency, driver-assist features, and bold aesthetics. If you find a 2020+ used Highlander in your budget, it’s a jackpot.


Benefits of Buying a Used Toyota Highlander

🧰 Reliability and Longevity

Toyota’s are famously reliable, and the Highlander is no exception. Many owners report getting well over 200,000 miles with regular maintenance.

💸 Cost Savings Compared to New Models

Depreciation hits new cars hard in the first few years. Let someone else take the hit—buying used can mean thousands in savings.

📈 High Resale Value

Because Highlanders are in high demand, they retain value better than many other SUVs in the market.

⛽ Fuel Efficiency and Hybrid Options

Used hybrid Highlanders are a dream—some models get over 30 mpg, which is rare for a 7-passenger vehicle.


🧑‍🔧 Common Features Found in Used Toyota Highlanders

🛋 Interior Comfort and Space

Even older Highlanders offer plush seating, roomy third rows, and smart cargo configurations. Leather, heated seats, and panoramic sunroofs are common in upper trims.

📱 Infotainment Systems

You’ll find touchscreens, Bluetooth connectivity, navigation, and even rear-seat entertainment in newer used models.

🛡 Safety Features and Ratings

Toyota loads its vehicles with safety tech. Expect lane departure alerts, adaptive cruise control, and high crash-test ratings even on older models.


🔍 Which Year Models Are Most Reliable?

👍 Best Years to Buy

  • 2016–2019: Excellent reliability, modern features, solid safety scores.

  • 2013: Last of Gen 2, known for bulletproof durability.

  • 2020+: Best if you can find a deal on newer tech.

⚠️ Years to Approach with Caution

  • 2008–2010: Some owners reported transmission and oil leak issues.

  • Always get a pre-purchase inspection regardless of year.


🛠 What to Look for When Buying a Used Toyota Highlander

📊 Mileage and Maintenance Records

Anything under 100,000 miles is fair game, but how it’s been maintained matters more. Ask for full service history.

📋 Vehicle History Report

Run the VIN through services like Carfax or AutoCheck to check for prior accidents or flood damage.

🔧 Mechanical Inspection Tips

Bring a trusted mechanic to inspect brakes, suspension, and fluids. Listen for odd noises during the test drive.

🔍 Signs of Accidents or Repairs

Mismatched paint, uneven panel gaps, and airbag light warnings are red flags.


💵 Pricing Guide for Used Toyota Highlanders

📈 Factors That Affect Price

  • Model Year

  • Trim Level (L, LE, XLE, Limited, Platinum)

  • Mileage

  • Condition

  • Location

💰 Average Price Ranges by Year and Trim

Year Average Price
2013 $11,000 – $16,000
2016 $17,000 – $24,000
2019 $25,000 – $32,000
2021 $30,000 – $40,000

🏅 Certified Pre-Owned vs Regular Used

CPO Highlanders are dealer-inspected, low-mileage vehicles with extended warranties. You’ll pay more, but the peace of mind is worth it for some buyers.


🏪 Where to Buy a Used Toyota Highlander

🚗 Dealerships vs Private Sellers

Dealers offer more protection and sometimes warranties. Private sales may be cheaper but riskier.

🌐 Online Marketplaces and Tools

Use trusted platforms like:

  • Autotrader

  • CarGurus

  • CarMax

  • Facebook Marketplace

✔ Certified Pre-Owned Programs

Toyota’s CPO program includes a 160-point inspection, 7-year powertrain warranty, and roadside assistance.


💳 Financing and Insurance for a Used Toyota Highlander

🏦 Loan Options for Used Vehicles

Banks, credit unions, and dealerships all offer financing. Rates may be slightly higher for used cars, but shopping around helps.

🧾 Insurance Rates and Factors

The Highlander is seen as a safe, reliable SUV—great for families. That means typically lower insurance premiums.


🧪 Test Driving a Used Toyota Highlander

👂 What to Pay Attention To

  • Strange engine noises

  • Transmission hesitation

  • Brake responsiveness

  • Suspension smoothness

❓ Questions to Ask the Seller or Dealer

  • Why are you selling?

  • Any recalls?

  • Has it been in an accident?

  • When were brakes and tires last replaced?


👨‍👩‍👧 Used Toyota Highlander for Families

🧳 Cargo Space and Seating Flexibility

Third-row seating, fold-flat configurations, and rear climate controls make it a winner for family road trips.

🛡 Safety Ratings for Family Use

NHTSA and IIHS consistently rate the Highlander highly for frontal and side crash protection.


🏕 Used Toyota Highlander for Outdoor Lovers

🚐 Towing Capacity

Can tow up to 5,000 lbs when properly equipped—great for boats, campers, or trailers.

❄️ All-Wheel Drive Capabilities

Many trims come with AWD, perfect for snow, gravel, or off-road adventures.


⚖️ Comparing the Highlander with Competitors

Honda Pilot

Similar size and reliability. Highlander wins on fuel economy and resale value.

Ford Explorer

More powerful engines, but lower reliability scores and resale value than Highlander.

Subaru Ascent

Great AWD system and safety, but has had more reliability concerns than Highlander.


Pros and Cons of Buying a Used Toyota Highlander

✔ Pros

  • Exceptional reliability

  • Comfortable for families

  • Good resale value

  • Available hybrid models

✖ Cons

  • Third-row space is tight for adults

  • Slightly more expensive than rivals

  • Some model years had tech that felt dated


🏁 Conclusion

Buying a used Toyota Highlander is one of the smartest SUV purchases you can make. Whether you’re looking for a family hauler, a road trip companion, or just a safe and solid ride, the Highlander delivers. With a little research and a solid inspection, you’ll drive away with a reliable vehicle that’s built to last.


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. How many miles can a Toyota Highlander last?
With proper maintenance, 250,000+ miles is very possible.

2. Is a used Toyota Highlander a good investment?
Yes, due to its reliability and strong resale value.

3. Are Highlanders good in the snow?
Absolutely, especially AWD versions.

4. Which Highlander trim is best for families?
The XLE trim offers a great mix of comfort, features, and price.

5. What are common issues in used Highlanders?
Occasional transmission issues in 2008–2010 models, and some complaints about infotainment lags in early 2010s trims.

You May Also Like:

Toyota Highlander for Sale: Everything You Need to Know